How to Choose the Best Recruiting Software For Your Needs - A Tailored Guide

Choosing the right recruiting software for your exact needs can be a challenge, particularly because there are so many options. 

Do you want an Applicant Tracking System to manage candidate data and applications? Do you need a candidate relationship management tool to help you build and maintain relationships with passive candidates?

Picking one tool can be a struggle, but in this post, we will highlight how to choose the best recruiting software for your exact needs. 

Different Types of Recruitment Software

As stated earlier, there are different types of recruitment software to choose from. Let’s explore them below. 

Applicant Tracking System

An ATS is an all-in-one management system for applicant data, job postings, emails, resumes, etc. More than 90% of recruiters and recruitment agencies use an ATS to keep track of applicants throughout the hiring process. A typical Applicant Tracking System has features like candidate screening, candidate database, resume parsing, and other collaborative tools. An ATS becomes necessary if you find yourself struggling to keep track of applicant details, setting up interviews, and just feeling overwhelmed by having to manage a large volume of applicant information. 

Candidate Relationship Management Tool

The success of a recruiter is often determined by the extent and qualifications of the talent pool. A candidate relationship management tool (CRM) helps recruiters create and manage talent pools while building and maintaining relationships with passive talent. Studies show that 64% of recruiting companies find CRM tools very helpful for their businesses. 

Recruitment Marketing Tools

Any recruiter's goal is to attract top talent in their industry, and recruitment marketing tools help with this. Recruiters use these tools to build stellar talent pipelines and streamline, automate, and improve all recruitment marketing operations to ensure the right talent sees your job opportunities and applies to them. 

Choosing Recruiting Software Based on Company Size 

Recruiters choose recruiting software based on company size, hiring volume, and operational complexity. For example, a small agency may need a simple ATS that can track and manage applicant information. However, a large enterprise may need a recruitment system with more features, such as marketing, candidate relationship management, etc.

For Small Agencies & Startups

Small businesses and startups usually have limited hiring budgets, mainly because they are not looking to hire too many people in a short period. So, they need user-friendly, cost-effective solutions that simplify recruitment and are easy to use.

Features to Look For:

• Job posting across multiple platforms: Provides maximum visibility for job listings.
• Basic automation: Helps with resume screening and interview scheduling.
• Collaboration tools: Allows smooth communication between hiring managers and team members.
• Customizable workflows: Allows simple tracking of candidates through the hiring process.
• Affordable and scalable: Ensures the software grows with the company’s needs.

Example tools: VIVAHR, Workable

For Midsize Companies

Midsize businesses handle a higher volume of job applications than startups and require more advanced automation, analytics, and integration to optimize their hiring processes.

Features to Look For:

• Automated workflows: Speeds up recruitment by automating approvals, follow-ups, and status updates.
• Advanced analytics & reporting: Provides deeper insights into hiring trends, time-to-fill metrics, and candidate pipeline health.
• Integration with HR systems: Allows seamless connection with payroll, onboarding, and performance management tools.
• Candidate Relationship Management (CRM): Helps maintain engagement with potential hires over time.

Example tools: Promap AI, SmartRecruiters, Greenhouse.

• Diversity & inclusion features: Supports unbiased hiring through structured interview processes and anonymized screening.

For Large Enterprises

Enterprise-level organizations manage high-volume recruitment across multiple locations and departments, requiring AI-driven automation, deep analytics, and compliance management.

Features to Look For:

• AI-powered candidate matching: Uses machine learning and NLP to recommend top candidates based on job requirements.
• Enterprise-grade security & compliance: Ensures 100% data protection and compliance with legal hiring regulations worldwide.
• Scalability & customization: Adapts to complex workflows, multiple hiring teams, and global operations.
• Predictive analytics: Forecasts hiring trends, workforce needs, and time-to-hire improvements.
• Advanced collaboration & approvals: Facilitates smooth communication between HR, department heads, and decision-makers.

Example tools: SAP SuccessFactors, Workday

Tips on Choosing the Right Recruitment Software for Your Needs

Regardless of your company size, certain tips will help you choose the right software for your needs. Here are some tips to help you make the right decision. 

Figure out your needs and wants

Recruitment software can be expensive, and it's easy to get carried away by the many exciting features and perks that come with each tool. However, it's important to figure out what your business needs and wants are to make the right decision. For example, if you are recruiting for multiple entry-level roles and most of your candidates come from job boards, recruitment software that allows you to post on multiple job boards at once is the best fit for you. 

Choose your must-have features.

There are certain non-negotiable features you need in a recruitment tool, and once you decide what these features are, it becomes easy to narrow down your options. For example, if you are struggling with manually entering candidates’ CV information into a central database, a resume parser will come in handy. Also, if you want to ensure you’re being compliant when handling candidate information and throughout the process, choosing a recruitment software with provisions for EE and GDPR is necessary. Once you decide on the features you absolutely need, you will be able to choose a tool easily. 

Pick a tool with great customer support.

Many recruitment software, especially those targeted at enterprise businesses, comes with a learning curve, and the HR team may struggle to get the hang of the tool in the beginning. It is important to choose a provider with reliable customer support so they can fix any issues that may arise. Reliable customer service should be available throughout the set-up and implementation process to fix any bug issues and ensure a smooth transition. 

Easy integrations

Switching from one tool to another when handling recruitment tasks can be a hassle. Choose recruitment software that allows easy and seamless integrations with other tools, such as your ATS, social media platforms, job boards, and communication tools. This way, data isn’t lost, and there is a seamless flow of information between apps. 

For instance, Promap has an inbuilt ATS that recruiters can use. However, the platform allows easy integrations with other ATS such as Greenhouse, BambooHR, ZohoRecruit, etc. 

Mobile recruitment

This Glassdoor study shows that 58% of candidates look for jobs on their phones, and 35% of job seekers prefer to apply for jobs on their phones. Recruiters cannot keep overlooking mobile recruitment, and the AI hiring tool you choose should have this feature, especially if you are also hiring remotely. Gone are the days when candidates were expected to only apply to jobs using a computer. Today, candidates expect easier and faster application processes that are accessible via mobile. Also, recruiters want to have access to their recruitment processes on their phones so they can work on the go. 

Seek community recommendations

The global recruiter community often shares tips on which tools are the best for different needs, and it's important to get their input when choosing a tool. For example, the recruiter community on Reddit often shares input on best hiring practices and which tools are the most affordable or offer the best features, etc. This kind of information is extremely valuable when you are trying to upgrade your recruitment software. 

Ensure the tool is customizable.

Every company’s recruitment needs are different, so you want recruitment software that you can adapt to work for your company’s exact needs. You don’t want software that forces you to conform to its rigid structure and leaves no room for adaptation. Choose a tool that allows you to add unique templates and build a custom hiring pipeline that works for your business. 

Why Choosing the Right Recruitment Software Matters

The right recruitment software can save time, reduce hiring costs, and help recruiters secure top talent faster. Here’s why selecting the right solution matters.

Speeds Up the Hiring Process

Recruiters handle multiple tasks daily, from sourcing candidates to scheduling interviews and reviewing applications. Without the right software, these tasks can become overwhelming and slow. For example, a small company relying on spreadsheets and email to track applicants may struggle to keep up as hiring needs grow. If this company uses a well-equipped ATS instead to automate resume screening, shortlist candidates based on keywords, and schedule interviews, the process will be a lot faster, and recruiters will focus on connecting with top candidates.

Improves Candidate Experience

A slow or unorganized hiring process can frustrate applicants and cause them to drop out of the process. When candidates don’t receive timely updates or face a complicated application process, they may lose interest in the role. A good recruiting system ensures that applications are mobile-friendly, easy to complete, and provide status updates at every stage. For instance, a company using automated email responses can keep candidates informed about their application progress. An AI recruitment tool with built-in video interviewing features can conduct interviews at scale without human intervention and take note of outstanding candidates without human intervention. This keeps candidates engaged throughout the hiring process, which improves their overall experience. 

Enhances Collaboration Among Hiring Teams

Recruitment often involves multiple people, from HR professionals to department managers and executives. Without a centralized system, feedback can get lost in long email chains, and decision-making can be slow. With the right AI hiring software, all stakeholders can access candidate profiles, leave feedback, and track progress in real time. For example, a hiring manager reviewing a candidate can leave notes directly in the system, allowing recruiters to move forward quickly without waiting for separate meetings or emails.

Ensures Compliance & Reduces Hiring Bias

Companies must follow legal hiring practices, such as data protection laws (GDPR) and equal employment regulations (EEOC). The right recruiting software helps businesses stay compliant by tracking hiring data and ensuring a fair selection process. For instance, some AI hiring software can anonymize resumes to remove names and personal details, allowing hiring managers to focus on skills and experience rather than unconscious biases. This promotes diversity and fair hiring practices while reducing the risk of discrimination claims.

Uses Data & AI for Smarter Hiring Decisions

Modern recruiting software provides valuable insights through data and artificial intelligence. Instead of relying on guesswork, businesses can analyze hiring trends, track time-to-hire, and identify the best sources for candidates. For example, a company noticing that most of its successful hires come from employee referrals can adjust its recruitment strategy to prioritize referral programs. AI-powered software can also suggest the best candidates for a role by analyzing past hiring patterns, helping businesses make more informed decisions.

FAQs

What is the best software for recruitment?

Promap AI is the best recruitment software for streamlining hiring processes. It removes manual bottlenecks, ensures bias-free interviews, and reduces interview rounds by 80%. 

How to choose an ATS?

When choosing an ATS, consider factors like company size, hiring volume, user experience, automation features, integration with existing tools, compliance, and customer support. 

What is a CRM in recruiting?

A CRM (Candidate Relationship Management) system in recruiting helps recruiters build and maintain relationships with potential hires. It stores candidate information, tracks communication, and nurtures talent pipelines, making it easier to engage passive candidates and fill future job openings without starting from scratch. 

How Promap AI Handles Your Recruiting Needs. 

Promap AI is designed to make hiring faster, fairer, and more efficient for both employers and candidates. Whether you're a startup making your first hires or a growing business scaling your team, Promap AI simplifies every step of the recruitment process.

Promap For Employers:

• Faster, Smarter Hiring
• Bias-Free Selection
• Expert AI interviewers trained in hard and soft skills
• Interviewing at scale without human input
• Save money and improve productivity. 

For Talent:

• Fewer, more meaningful interviews 
• Transparent hiring process with no bias
• Fair & skills-based assessments with career development tips

Promap AI is more than just recruitment software; it’s a smarter way to build high-performing teams. Get started with a FREE DEMO today!

‍